Listen
Posted by Mishi Methven on Apr 21, 2012
Listen
Listen. What do you hear?
I can tell you what I used to hear around this time last year. The phone blaring in my ear. My toddler Stella's feet echoing as she ran around in green froggy rain boots--- probably not listening to me, probably pulling all kinds of things out of her toy box or the bathroom cabinets. The TV was probably on CP24 news so we could keep abreast of road closures, weather, top news stories, etc. Aimee and I would be talking about all the things we had to get done on the short weekend…who was going to do the laundry, grocery shopping, empty the dishwasher, how I would fit study time in, what play date we had planned to help fill Stella's day and make it a little less chaotic by keeping her busy. There would be the sounds of dishes clanging as we piled them in the sink, Stella demanding more butter on whatever it was she was eating, the dog barking every time someone walked past the house. It was a whirlwind of dates on the calendar, rushing around in a fruitless balancing act of home, work, school, family, friends.
Listen. What do you hear?
I hear the TV droning on in the background but no one is watching it. I hear Stella's steady breathing as she is tucked under my left arm on the couch, a sprinkling of sweat on her nose where I always thought the freckles would come when she got older. I hear an army of birds chirping in the tree outside. A car door slamming. Aimee is quietly singing something to Sam as she wanders around the house, moving piles of unopened bills from one side of the room to the other.
Listen. What do you hear?
I can tell you what I don't hear. I don't hear the soft smack of of bare feet running on the wood floors. I don't hear the crashing of toys being picked up and moved around in the toy box. I don't hear the phone ringing as I try to organize multiple play dates. I don't hear Aimee and I breathlessly trying to catch each other up on our days, what needs to be done, our plans for the next several days. Aimee and I spend a lot of time in silence now, adrift in our own thoughts and at a complete loss as to what to say to one another. We express our feelings through tears, gentle pats on the knee, hugs as we pass each other in the kitchen. Laughter and smiles too, on the many occasions we are able to appreciate the everyday wonderment of our lives, and our amazing children. But a lot of the time we just sit quietly together.
This week, despite a good week for Stella in which she enjoyed incredible activities like horseback riding, swimming, visits, feeding birds, a trip to the farm and music therapy, there has been one thing missing. Her voice. Even though Stella's speech had been declining for some time now, it seems that even the most basic words…"yes"…"no"…"more", and worst of all, "mama" and "mommy"are now gone. Of all the things that have been so cruelly taken from Stella, for me this has been the hardest to deal with. It is heartbreaking to watch her mouth move, knowing her brain has the exact right words she wants to say, but her tongue lolls uselessly back and forth and the only sounds that come out are high pitched animal-like whines. It's awful. There is no other way to describe or sugar-coat it. I imagine it akin to being buried alive, where your brain is working perfectly but you are trapped and unable to move or tell anyone where you are. Aimee and I can each only stand by, watching her struggle to speak for short periods of time, then we have to change who is sitting with her because it quickly becomes unbearable. We try our best to distract her, to make her laugh, to guess what she might want. But it makes your chest ache with how hard it is to listen to the silence where her chit-chat used to be. It makes your eyes burn with unshed tears when you see Sam sitting and happily babbling while his sister stares at us, desperately trying to communicate with her eyes and facial expressions. I hate this part. It hurts.
Now Aimee and I often fill the silence by trying to remember all the things Stella used to say to us. Her first word was "dog", and she would point to Lucy and say "dawd" then scream with laughter. She called dandelions "candy-lions", and often referred to Aimee as "other Mommy". She called the two parks by our house "Sandwich" (real name: Aldwych), and "Holy Cow" (real name Holy Cross). Her grey cat doll was "Fluff-ellie", her corduroy one was "Pink Kitty", and one of her favourites she referred to as "Little Arin", after her friend Arin. She named her first talking dolly "Rocco" and her second "Cinderella". She knew all the lyrics to the Golden Girls theme song as well as all the characters names, and called the show "Thank-you for being a friend". She used to wake us up every morning, 7 days a week, at 5:15am by standing up in her crib and shouting "Mamaaaaaa, where are you???? Mamaaaaaa I'm awaaaaaake!". For breakfast she asked for "crunchy cereal". When she was put into bed and wasn't ready to go to sleep, she would cry and call out the names of every single person she knew tearfully, including her friends and their parents begging someone---anyone to come and get her. She thought Halle Barry on TVwas our friend Jean, and Sharon Osbourne was her Tutu. When we visited Riverdale Farm, she plugged her nose and said, "Piggies, you stink! You should pee in the potty!" and she would say when she saw the chickens coming, "uh-oh, now Mommy is going to freak out" because she thoroughly enjoyed Aimee's reaction of jumping on benches and trying desperately to shoo the chickens away from her ankles. If she didn't like someone, she would simply point her finger at them, narrow her eyes and say loudly "I don't like you!". When she got in trouble, if we asked her why she did something she would blink her eyelashes a few times, spread her arms wide open and say, smiling, "Because...because...because I JUST love you!!!". She was vivacious, talkative, spirited, full of life. She is still all these things, but now Aimee and I fill in what we think her thoughts and words are for her. Just like with a baby, we will say to her, "Stella say thank-you", but then knowing she can't, we continue by saying on her behalf in the first person, "thank-you Christina for coming to play with me today". I wonder if she gets annoyed when we do that. Sometimes when people come in I can see her narrowing her eyes and moving her hands back and forth. I know if she had a voice she would be telling our visitors to "go away!". But because she can't say it, Aimee and I will patronizingly say, "Yeah Stella, are you saying hi to Kayla? Hi Kayla! Thank-you for coming to see me!" in order to protect the visitors' feelings. Stella sometimes glares at me when I do that to her. And I feel badly, knowing that her silence must be stifling for her and what she really wants me to say is, "Stella doesn't want you here. Get out".
I am upset that she has been cruelly quieted by this tumour. I wonder how long Aimee and I will last suffering in this silence with her. Today I was thinking about how, despite how honest Aimee and I have tried to be with everyone, despite the blog, confiding in friends and family, crying loudly and often, despite all that--- most of our experiences remain unsayable. We wrestle everyday to express thoughts and emotions that are, ultimately, indescribable. Our life experience over the last 10 months is largely beyond words, and so exists in a type of paradox balancing emptiness and wholeness, the spoken and the unspoken.
Listen. What do you hear?
I am now listening to music as I finish typing this entry. I am listening to my newly discovered favourite band, "The Stellas" (of course!). They have a song called In This House, which is almost too close for comfort. But it starts:
All is quiet
In our humble home.
Lonely,
But I'm not alone
Cuz I can hear your laugh in every room…
(You can listen to the song here, if you want: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CEAOY3ZIKQ)
And I realize that even though I miss Stella's voice, and cry whenever I conceive that I may never hear her say "Mama" to me again, we still have the sound of Stella's laugh echoing off our walls and our hearts. She can't talk, she can't cry tears--- but she still laughs. Pretty amazing.
This reminded me that if you listen to a really good piece of music, you soon realize that the notes are part of the song, but the pauses and silences between the notes are just as important to the artistry of the piece. The vibrations, the pitch, the tone, the duration of breaths taken all combine to create the full experience of form, harmony, and expression of emotion. The music wouldn't be music without the silences in-between notes.
Listen. What do you hear?
I hear my heart, breaking and healing with every beat. I hear all the memories of the last three years with Stella competing for airtime in my mind. I hear Stella breathing steadily, and in the half-second of silence between the inhale and exhale, I hear the word "listen".
These pictures from the last week have no words, but I bet you can understand them perfectly anyhow:

Comments (14)
Cathy:
Apr 26, 2012 at 10:53 PM
Aimee & Mish, your and your children are in my thoughts daily.
I have a 16-year-old who is not verbal and as I was reading this post I wondered if the communication device he uses might help. It's a low-tech device called a GoTalk that allows the communicator to make choices to express a pre-recorded request. I'm not sure if Stella would be able to see the visuals in order to choose, though; or if she could activate the choices with a supported hand? Here is a link: http://www.bindependent.com/gotalk.htm If you think it might be a viable option, I would be happy to co-ordinate community donations to pay for it. I can be reached at East End Children's Centre. Love to you all.
Jen:
Apr 26, 2012 at 10:36 PM
I have followed you blog from almost the begining and I now struggle to read many of your posts. I think there was part of me that really thought that Stella would be that 1 in a million, the one that beat the odds. As I read this message, the reality is completely sinking in...... I have a little boy who is almost the same age as Stella to the day. I could hear his voice as I read this post and the tears started....... I do not know you, but if I had just one wish, I would use it to help Stella. You and your family are always in my thoughts and I wish there was more that any of us could do to help. Please give Stella a very big hug and let her know that there is a whole group of people out in the world who think she is a very brave little girl and we are all wishing we could help more.....
Omo:
Apr 26, 2012 at 08:22 PM
Holy moly Mish,
It's so interesting that I should read this today. It was great to see you all today and to play with darling Sam & beautiful Stella. April has been the month of great anger for me around this whole thing and I'm especially furious today! This whole experience is a travesty!!! But her not being able to communicate at all is a whole new depth. I had a good cry a little while ago about the fact that I would probably never hear her say my name again. The way she always used to end a sentence with my name as if to make sure I was listening. "Where's my Arin, Omo?" But, that was my own private little sadness about the way we used to be but it was still joyous to hear her voice. As it took more and more effort for her to get the words out, my heart always celebrated hearing them because it was a sign that our Stella was still with us and was fighting as hell to be heard cause how else was she going to tell us who or what she wanted or didn't want around. It shattered my heart to see her try to say something to me today and to not be able to do it. There really are no words. I want to say to whoever it is that's got any power over this situation "have you absolutely no decency that you can do this? Isn't she already suffering enough? Isn't it enough that she's going to die?"
I'd love to end on a happy note but I can't right now. If I think of a joke, I'll call you with it but I just felt like i needed to say publicly to whoever it is that has power over this situation that I'm pissed off and disgusted that this could be happening to Stella. All of it but especially this new development. I'm so MAD ABOUT IT!!!!
Shauna MacKenzie:
Apr 26, 2012 at 01:19 PM
I still think of you and your family often, and Stella never leaves my mind. My heart breaks with every post that I read, and it leaves me feeling connected to you and your pain. Thank you for sharing the photos above, they are beyond precious and they do say so much...love, happiness, family.
~Shauna
Anne:
Apr 26, 2012 at 11:18 AM
I recently stumbled across your blog and I just wanted to tell you how much my heart goes out to you. Little Stella is an amazing child and so beautiful. While he stay on earth will only be short, she has been loved and blessed to have two amazing mommies. My thoughts and prayers are with you.
Melanie Hepburn:
Apr 24, 2012 at 10:13 AM
I lost someone close to me after watching them suffer and all I can say is work thru the anger..be angry be loud be crazy....it's okay. Be pissed at the 'Gods', be pissed at your friends, be pissed...it's okay. It's a fawked up situation and no words of inspiration will make this situation less fawked up.
Lynn:
Apr 24, 2012 at 01:59 AM
I think of you every day. Love to you all. You are never alone.
Cate Creede:
Apr 23, 2012 at 01:25 PM
This took my breath away, Mishi.
I hear my heart, breaking and healing with every beat. I hear all the memories of the last three years with Stella competing for airtime in my mind. I hear Stella breathing steadily, and in the half-second of silence between the inhale and exhale, I hear the word "listen".
I'm listening with all of you.
Deb:
Apr 23, 2012 at 12:35 PM
Hey Mish, Aim (Stella and Sam) and Lucy, thinking about you this morning. Thinking about how much water has passed under the bridge in the last 3 years. I look at the pics of Rae holding Stella as a newborn so often. That is a treasured family pic. We're here. We've always been here and will be here when you come up for air.
Mary:
Apr 23, 2012 at 12:24 PM
What a gift she has given you. The chance to see her face light up as she sees her beautiful cupcake birthday cake. She may not understand how her body is changing, but boy o' boy does she ever understand "birthdays" and a birthday cake. You've given her the most treasured gift of that pleasure - one more time. And she has given you both her gift - a beautiful memory of that amazing smile, one that doesn't need to be able to say the words out loud - words of "I love you" - and "this is the best birthday cake ever!". The best birthday gifts of all - in bright blue eyes and a smile that says it all. Thinking and praying for you all - always.
Go to Comment Page 1 2